Chisholm v. Georgia (1793)

Chisholm v. Georgia is the most famous and the most important of the U.S. Supreme Court's eighteenth-century decisions. The Court's ruling arose out of the sale of supplies during the Revolutionary War (1775-83) made on credit to the state of Georgia by a South Carolina merchant, Captain Robert Farquhar. Georgia later refused to pay for the goods, because Farquhar was a British loyalist. After Farquhar died, however, the executor of his estate, Alexander Chisholm, who also hailed from South Carolina, brought an action on the still-uncollected account (as permitted by the then-operative federal jurisdictional statute) in the Supreme Court of the United States. Upon receiving notice of the action, Georgia refused to appear in court. It asserted that, as a sovereign state, it possessed immunity from the suit, absent its consent, even though Article III of the U.S. Constitution specifies that federal courts have jurisdiction to decide cases "between a State and citizens of another State." Citing this text, the Supreme Court rejected Georgia's sovereign-immunity argument and ordered Georgia to pay Chisholm the money damages he sought.
In the wake of this decision, however, howls of protest rose throughout the country. Within five years, U.S. Congress had proposed and the states had ratified the Eleventh Amendment, which overturned the principle of the Chisholm decision by providing that "the Judicial power of the United States shall not be construed to extend to any suit in law or equity, commenced or prosecuted against one of the United States by Citizens of another State."
To this day, Chisholm stands as one of only a handful of Supreme Court rulings that have been overturned by constitutional amendment. Even more important, the Supreme Court has built on the repudiation of Chisholm to hold that the Eleventh Amendment exemplifies a sovereign-immunity principle that sweeps well beyond the amendment's text. Invoking this principle, the court has sheltered states from almost all money-damage actions brought in any court, even when initiated by a state's own residents based on clear violations of federal statutory law.
close

Loading

Cite This Article
Coenen, Dan T. "Chisholm v. Georgia (1793)." New Georgia Encyclopedia. 17 May 2016. Web. 14 November 2020.
From Our Home Page
Natural History of the Okefenokee Swamp

The largest swamp in North America, the Okefenokee Swamp covers roughly 700 square miles and is located in the southeastern corner of Georgia,

Read more...
Tattnall County

Located in the Lower Coastal Plain of southeast

Read more...
Mattie Lee Sigers

Mattie Lee Sigers's fiber

Read more...
Georgia Southern Football

The Georgia Southern Eagles are the most successful program in the history of National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) I-AA football, winning six national championships between 1985 and 2000

Read more...
Courtesy of Hargrett Rare Book and Manuscript Library, University of Georgia Libraries